Current Features

Gouverneur Morris
America: A Christian Nation?
Ya Gotta Have Faith!
Not-Hearing: Two Examples
The Paradox of Public Advertising
Cleave; Sanction
Doomsday Clock: False Authority Fallacy
Politicians and Their Children
Eric Boehlert Knows Inner Motives!
What is the Purpose of Democracy?
One Mess Created, Time to Create Another
Christians Pursuing Happiness

Read the Front Page

Topics

Big Brother
Blogging
Computers and Technology
Crime and Punishment
Education
Entertainment
Europe
Everything You Know is Wrong
Faith and Philosophy
Faith and Politics
Features
France
Fun
General
Happy Stuff
Health
History
Human Rights
Humor
International
Iraq
Left Versus Right
Media Bias
Personal Notes
Politics
Product Reviews
Quick Alerts
Quixtar
Racism
Science
Science Fiction
Sexuality
Sick & Wrong Department
Society
The Arab Street
The Arts
The Church of Gaia
Travel
Words, Words, Words
Your Money

Archives

January 2007
December 2006
November 2006
October 2006
September 2006
August 2006
July 2006
June 2006
May 2006
April 2006
March 2006
February 2006
January 2006
December 2005
November 2005
October 2005
September 2005
August 2005
July 2005
June 2005
May 2005
April 2005
March 2005
February 2005
January 2005
December 2004
November 2004
October 2004
September 2004
August 2004
July 2004
June 2004
May 2004
April 2004
March 2004
February 2004
January 2004
December 2003
November 2003
October 2003
September 2003
August 2003
July 2003
June 2003
May 2003
April 2003
March 2003
February 2003
January 2003

Search


The Blogosphere

BitsBlog
Beyond the Rim
Common Sense and Wonder
Dissecting Leftism
Drive-Thru Musings
FunMurphys.com
Insignificant Thoughts
Insomnomaniac
Investor Blogger
Iowa Geek
La Shawn Barber
The Littlest Apologist
Mark D. Roberts
Quixtar Blog
Quixtar Sucks
The Right Scale
Sinking in Quixand


The Philosophical Inconsistency of the Left

Kevin from FunMurphys inadvertantly pushes one of my buttons in a comment regarding Boycott France?:

If a woman has the right to choose, doesn't every American have the right to choose what country they want their merchandise from?

Although the original question concerned the attitudes of people in other countries, he raises a interesting issue. While its not true of all, it seems that in recent years "the left" has largely abandoned any consistent philosophical underpinning and reduced their dogmatic canon to a number of unconnected, conflicting "special cases" and fiats...

For example, as Kevin notes, a woman has a right to choose, a right to determine what happens with her body. Except in China, where her right to choose is less important than the "needs" of the state. Or in India, where a woman has a right to choose an abortion, but feminists lobbied to ensure she doesn't have the right to another private medical treatment, ultrasound, which will help her determine if the child is female and should thus be aborted. And, in New York and California, the doctor no longer has the right to choose; an intern can no longer use the conscience clause to opt out of abortion and must be trained to perform them. (This is true even when the doctor is a woman and must use her body to perform the abortion.)

And of course discriminating on the basis of race and gender is right if it appears, at least superficially, that that motive is to improve that minority's status, but is wrong if it doesn't (in that superficial analysis, deeper analysis are prohibited) or merely opposes some already canonized leftist dogma.

Freedom of speech is to be cherished, but we should bring the coercive powers of the state or other duly constituted authority (university, city) against you if you use those powers to oppose an ideal of the left. (Cite: David Horowitz on reparations.) Religious folks should not avail themselves of this right. Unless your religion is a "tolerant" one, like Buddhism. Except for Islam, which is to be accepted even though its intolerant.

Gun ownership is immoral, unless you have the money to hire your own security firm. Violence is bad and wrong, unless its in my last movie, or a movie with my favorite star in it. Then, viewing or speaking of violence is a matter of choice, opposing it is censorship. Except, in cases we disagree with, such as where the violence appears to be racially-motivated. Except in cases where that violence is directed against Jews by Muslims. Then its okay again.

Pornography is wrong: it degrades women. Or is it right, because conservatives are opposed to it and Woody Harrelsen seems so sympathetic when he portrays Larry Flynn? We're not sure yet about this one.

Civil disobedience is an important "right", and civil disobedience is patriotic. Those behaving thusly should be treated with respect and allowed to finish their protest. Unless you're protesting abortion or another cherished leftist dogma. Then you need to be prosecuted under RICO (designed for the mafia) and the ACLU need not be concerned violations of your civil liberties.

War is wrong, but "wars of liberation", such as the Palestinians against the Israelis, are right. Unless the "liberators" would institute a non-leftist government, such as the Contras or Polish Catholics. Military intervention from the outside is wrong. Except in Kosovo. And Serbia. The UN must be involved. Except when its clear that it's a corrupt institution. (We'll tell you when that is.)

Instead of war, or at least the wars I oppose, words and diplomacy be used to change the minds of these dictators. And no, no amount of words and diplomacy will change my mind on this matter. (Uh, wait, am I not saying I'm less reasonable than my own picture of, say, Saddam? Uh, next topic...)

Acceptable governments are those which believe in rule of law respect for human rights and dignity. Exceptions to the previous may be those which have a leftist leaning, like Cuba, China, North Korea, and Iraq. Exceptions to these exceptions include Islamic states, which, even though further "right" than U.S. Republicans, should be treated as a leftist because they're so darned "authentic" and "sincere": Muslims tend to be poor. Except that the Christians they kill in many wars of revolution are poorer, but owww! my head's starting to hurt now...

How is is possible to buy into this cognative dissonance?

Comments

Add your two cents...

The comment rules will apply. Please post only once.

















« Boycott France? | Front Page | Page Two | Absurd Legal Awards »