Current Features

Gouverneur Morris
America: A Christian Nation?
Ya Gotta Have Faith!
Not-Hearing: Two Examples
The Paradox of Public Advertising
Cleave; Sanction
Doomsday Clock: False Authority Fallacy
Politicians and Their Children
Eric Boehlert Knows Inner Motives!
What is the Purpose of Democracy?
One Mess Created, Time to Create Another
Christians Pursuing Happiness

Read the Front Page

Topics

Big Brother
Blogging
Computers and Technology
Crime and Punishment
Education
Entertainment
Europe
Everything You Know is Wrong
Faith and Philosophy
Faith and Politics
Features
France
Fun
General
Happy Stuff
Health
History
Human Rights
Humor
International
Iraq
Left Versus Right
Media Bias
Personal Notes
Politics
Product Reviews
Quick Alerts
Quixtar
Racism
Science
Science Fiction
Sexuality
Sick & Wrong Department
Society
The Arab Street
The Arts
The Church of Gaia
Travel
Words, Words, Words
Your Money

Archives

January 2007
December 2006
November 2006
October 2006
September 2006
August 2006
July 2006
June 2006
May 2006
April 2006
March 2006
February 2006
January 2006
December 2005
November 2005
October 2005
September 2005
August 2005
July 2005
June 2005
May 2005
April 2005
March 2005
February 2005
January 2005
December 2004
November 2004
October 2004
September 2004
August 2004
July 2004
June 2004
May 2004
April 2004
March 2004
February 2004
January 2004
December 2003
November 2003
October 2003
September 2003
August 2003
July 2003
June 2003
May 2003
April 2003
March 2003
February 2003
January 2003

Search


The Blogosphere

BitsBlog
Beyond the Rim
Common Sense and Wonder
Dissecting Leftism
Drive-Thru Musings
FunMurphys.com
Insignificant Thoughts
Insomnomaniac
Investor Blogger
Iowa Geek
La Shawn Barber
The Littlest Apologist
Mark D. Roberts
Quixtar Blog
Quixtar Sucks
The Right Scale
Sinking in Quixand


Kerry and Health Insurance: It Doesn't Add Up

Here's what John Kerry says he'll do to improve health care (from a speech in Iowa posted to his web site):

In my first 100 days as President, I'll offer America a real deal on health care that starts with cutting costs and stopping skyrocketing premiums...

The average health care cost per person in Iowa is about $4,000. Under my plan, you'll see real savings of up to $1,000 on that bill. That's $1,000 that can help buy groceries, pay the bills, and give your family a break.

Here's how we'll do it. Right now, only four out of every one thousand insurance claims deal with health care costs over $50,000. Insurance companies, however, end up spending a fifth of their expenses paying for these very few cases. If they're spending that much, you can bet everyone else's premiums are going to go up. Under my plan the government will pick up most of the tab for these expensive cases - and the premiums for middle-class families will go down.

So we're going to save money on healthcare by lowering insurance costs -- by having the government pay for any cases which cost an insurance company over $50,000. Passing the bill right back to ... us, the taxpayers and customers, again. Only with extra costs added by the government.

If every Iowan is paying $1,000 out of $4000 for each of these cases, it means they'll now have a $3000 insurance bill -- and probably be paying an extra $2000 in taxes! You can't get something for nothing.

Talk about favors for "special interests"! He'll be taking taxes of which amount to more than 25% of the total cost of health insurance and giving it to insurance companies, at taxpayer expense!

Alarmingly, it looks like this might create an incentive for insurance companies to move "marginal" cases into the more costly category. If it looks like a guy's bill might be $42,000, there is an incentive here to leave him in the hospital until the bill passes $50K, adding yet another $8,000 to what the taxpayer (who is probably also an insurance customer) has to pick up. If an insurance company can do this, it will drive it's average costs down, and make it appear to offer a lower-cost insurance product to customers than competitors who do not -- so the pressure will be for everyone in the industry to start doing this.

Undoubtedly, that'll give some future Democrat ammuntion for then complaining about the "corrupt" insurance industry, and his need to put it under more governmental control, or eliminate it altogether -- when perverse government incentives caused the problem in the first place!

Kerry says he'll fight medicare fraud. That's good, if true. (How much will that save us?) Yet Kerry also promises here that he'll give us much more benefits from "the government" (e.g. from us) and also slash bureaucracy. I guess he's counting on our desire to have it both ways. But sadly, there's no such thing as a free lunch.

You think healthcare is expensive now? Just wait until it's "free"!

Thanks to Steve Verdon for the heads-up.

UPDATE 10/31: It appears the goalposts have changed a little, but the fundamental problem remains. This is finally getting some dicussion.

Comments

I think you are on the right track. I am a big believer that when you get the incentives wrong, everything breaks down. And this approach is seriously getting the incentives wrong.

The only thing I can say that you've written might be a little iffy is:

"If every Iowan is paying $1,000 out of $4000 for each of these cases, it means they'll now have a $3000 insurance bill -- and probably be paying an extra $2000 in taxes!"

I suspect you are right, but I'm interested in where you came up with the number. Just guestimating? Or is there some math involved...

Posted by: on February 3, 2004 11:17 PM

Tim, thanks for pointing me to this post! Being from Taxachussets, I'm all too well-aquainted with Kerry/Kennedy "I'm gonna get you something for nothing, sort of" promises. What galls me though is how many of my "neighbors" believe this crap without questioning it. Even those who don't--who may flat-out hate the guy's positions--will support him through the election because, well, HEY, he's a hometown guy!

As with the Red Sox, people from this Godforesaken state (and I just live here, thank heaven I wasn't born here and didn't grow up here) have such an exaggerated sense of misguided, mindless loyalty, lemmings are hanging their heads in shame by comparison.

But what do I expect? We also have some of the worst public schools in the nation (which is beyond ironic considering we have the greatest number of "Institutions of Higher Learning" per capita in the country).

It's a two part process with the Dems:
1. Keep the populace as dumb and thoughtless as a box of rocks by blaming a failing system on something that has no "feelings" that can be hurt, and at the same time no capacity for rational thought (namely MONEY, or the lack thereof)

2. Keep the dumb populace poor by jacking taxes up so high that they are perpetually bitter and angry and in "need" of someone to blame (namely the government) for not helping them out

And the irony to end all ironies is that the same brain-dead morons who trashed parts of the city and even killed a kid in "celebration" of the "Pats" winning last Sunday refer to themselves (or at least puff out their chests when others refer to them this way) as the "Northeastern Elite."

Every time I think about the fact that I'm probably stuck in this region for life, I want to cry.

Posted by: Deb on February 5, 2004 04:13 AM

Add your two cents...

The comment rules will apply. Please post only once.

















« Bush and WMD | Front Page | Page Two | Sunnyside Elementary, Meet Handbasket »