|
Apparently, the actual neuroscientists over at New Scientist aren't looking at it 'logically' enough. Besides finding evidence, contra Dr. Maher, MD, that there are more factors involved than just nurture, they also note:
If getting along well with people, hard work, conscientiousness, punctuality, and impulse control are symptoms of a neurological 'disorder', I want to know: Where do I sign up? And is there another disorder I can 'contract' to become wealthy and stunningly good looking? Perhaps the last one would require a physical disorder. ;-) Of course, consider the contrapositive: if being "religious" increases these beneficial traits, it's also true being "irreligious" comparatively decreases them. Since being 'religious' is by far the norm, why are we studying it as though it were some odd ailment? And if there were an alternate state of mind which interefered with these positive behaviors, wouldn't that actually be a better candidate for a 'disorder' classification? I'm just sayin', is all.
Yes, if you want to find people who really love and are interested in science and 'rationality', go to Hollywood. ;-) Thanks for the somewhat-flawed lesson in neurology, Dr. Maher. In our next lesson, we will learn meterology and environmental science by watching "The Day After Tomorrow", and study geophysics from noted geologist Pierce Brosnan, via his award-winning documentary, "Volcano!" Finally, we'll all be treated to a discourse in formal reasoning from renowned philosopher Dr. Barbara Streisand, PhD. Add your two cents...
The comment rules will apply. Please post only once. |