|
Having a blog is a bit like having fishbowl. Sometimes, posts take on a life of their own. One of the hottest topics on this blog -- despite comprising only about 2% of the posts -- is Quixtar. I originally just went to the business meeting because a friend at church implored me to. At the last minute, she handed me off to her "upline" who gave me a presentation which was apparently designed to make me start to lust for material possessions, and thus devote my free time to doing something called "Quixtar". Unlike many, I wrote about my experiences, and my summary of what I thought was wrong with the business model I saw. Quixtar IBOs ("Independent Business Owners" -- people who participate in the "system") seem attracted to these articles like moths to a flame. New IBOs like to come here and type what they just heard from a tape or in a business meeting. (They often repeat each other, and miss the counter-arguments already answered.) And sometimes we hear from former IBOs who want to warn others, like Imran Aziz, who shares what he's learned from his in-depth experiences with Quixtar. Some of these former IBO testimonies can be moving. I recently received one such testimony from "Matt", which the few people left who have not heard of Quixtar might benefit from. Like so many new IBOs I meet these days, Matt was just out of college when he heard about Quixtar -- confirming my suspicion that Quixtar is on its last legs, and is collapsing, albeit slowly, even now:
Thank you, Matt. Matt, you are very unfortunate to have gone through that experience. I am a new IBO myself. my upline is very dedicated to me and helping me grow my business the best they can. They are professional businessmen and do not pressure me into anything. If I choose not to do something, they dont want me to do it...honestly. Being an IBO is a very respectable title to have. You just have to be willing to listen, learn and apply. Why get started with the business if your not willing to work? The statement you made about 1,000 people until diamond...is not true. It is all about how you and your upline structure your business. Its not all about getting as many people on your downline as possible, its about investing a majority of your time to 1 or 2 people in your downline at a time and produce a business relationship, but more importantly, a personal relationship that will benefit your future. This is a wonderful business, if you dont produce hard work, you will make little money, loose money, or break even. If you work hard at your business you can make as much money as you wish. People who have negative comments about IBO's are usually the ones that are not willing to work. If this business was not sucessfull, my upline would not be making over $60,000 / yr when he has only been in business for just under 3 years. The numbers are real...you just have to want them! Posted by: Neal on November 16, 2006 01:29 PM Good luck Neal. By the way, how do you know what your upline makes? Have you seen his/her profit/loss statements? Posted by: Joecool18 on December 12, 2006 05:19 PM Hi everyone im not too sure about the Quixtar but I just went to one of the meetings tonight and I thought it was very intersting and I gave it some thoughts and im going to give it a try... I found this blog by tring to further my intrest in IBO and how well it can be a asset to me .... Posted by: Craig on December 27, 2006 11:26 PM Craig, please read more articles on this blog. For most people who "try" quixtar, you will end up losing time and money. Ironically, time and money is probably what someone said you could get more of byy joining quixtar. Posted by: Joecool18 on December 28, 2006 01:56 AM Matt said " The entire time I was in 'the business' I just couldn't ignore the numbers. It took 1,000 people or so to 'make' a diamond. When they'd ask at a function "why aren't you all diamonds?" I thought the guy was completely stupid and wanted to shout "only 1 in 1,000 of us could be!"
Posted by: Joecool18 on February 15, 2007 05:47 PM Shaun said: I'm not sure what you people are talking about, but quixtar is the best thing that has ever happened to me. With-in the next two years I will be a DIAMOND!!!! So stop with your negitive mind set and get up and do somthing.
Posted by: Joecool18 on May 25, 2007 04:18 PM Being an IBO is the best thing that ever happened to me and frankly I say to you 50 yr plan for u 5 yr plan for me in financial freedom yay I win!! Posted by: Diamond!! on July 11, 2007 02:37 PM Diamond said: Being an IBO is the best thing that ever happened to me and frankly I say to you 50 yr plan for u 5 yr plan for me in financial freedom yay I win!!
Posted by: Joecool18 on July 12, 2007 12:09 PM what does that matter if they change their name to poop im still growing and making money Posted by: Diamond!! on August 1, 2007 03:21 PM Diamond said: what does that matter if they change their name to poop im still growing and making money
Posted by: Joecool18 on August 1, 2007 04:56 PM What I want to know is why those who have made it, uplines are they called?? Why none of THEM ever post anything? They are the ones who know the real deal. I have yet to hear of someone who has made thousands of dollars off of this, I have only come across hear say. I want to hear first hand. Posted by: TERRENCE on August 30, 2007 09:54 PM Terrence, there are some former diamonds who have come forward with their stories. These diamonds have said they made most of their money from the sale of tapes, books and seminar tickets and not from quixtar. I believe that to be true and I believe many downline are deceived into thinking that they will get rich from quixtar. Posted by: Joecool18 on September 6, 2007 07:44 PM I don’t know why are you giving your negative comments..have you really seen the real deal? What you are saying is probably the words of others who couldn’t do it.. when I first joined Quixtar, the first thing my upline told me was , “ its totally up to you how you handle this business..i have seen people who have covered the cost of registration in a month, I have seen who covered it in 6 months and I have seen who are in this business for more than a year and they are still unable to recover their cost ” Posted by: kp on September 25, 2007 09:45 AM kp said: So you see the deal here..its not about selling..its about sharing the opportunity and creating a network.. Joe says: That approach to this business makes it possibly an illegal pyramid. kp said: ( and yes I got $8 first month..$100 the second month..this is my third month and I ll be getting $200 +) so yea this thing is real !!
Buying double x for $78 instead of a multi vitamin for $15.99 at Costco doesn;t seem like a good value to me. Posted by: Joecool18 on September 25, 2007 12:28 PM yup..good questions joe..m glad.. i sponcored 3 people, who then sponcored few more..and i am not on standing order, my upline is providing the cds and books..but i am going to buy those eventually..and i went to one function "FED"..it cost me around $200 for the trip..well i dont see any waste here..it was worth it i know..it was an invesment made for myself.. and about dounlex well its not $78 its $52 for the ibos...and i cant explain this, you are a smart guy no doubt about that..do a little bit of research if u can abt these.you will find the answer...i use them and i love them !! Posted by: kp on September 29, 2007 06:01 AM kp, So, at the time you wrote the above, you had received $108, taxable, and spent $200 on one function. This is good? Posted by: jo on November 13, 2007 05:56 PM kp said: i sponcored 3 people, who then sponcored few more..and i am not on standing order, my upline is providing the cds and books..but i am going to buy those eventually..and i went to one function "FED"..it cost me around $200 for the trip..well i dont see any waste here..it was worth it i know..it was an invesment made for myself.. Joe says: So basically, your group is losing money - due to the functions, and eventually you will lose even more when you start buying your own tapes. If you enjoyed the function, that's great but what benefit was it to your business? kp said: and about dounlex well its not $78 its $52 for the ibos Joe says: Excuse me, I thought you sold those to customers once in a while. Even at $52, it's more than double the cost of multi vitamins that I can get at Costco. Oh, and Costco gives me a 3 month supply for less than half the price of a 30 day supply of double x. Posted by: Joecool18 on November 16, 2007 01:06 PM Yea, I would have quit talking to Joe too. It's what you make it! Spend little time, make little money. Spend a lot of time, make a lot of money! It isn't for everyone. Some people would rather sit at home and watch a movie instead of showing someone the plan. The plan is now available on line. Go find it! Then talk to an IBO. Posted by: David on May 29, 2008 04:58 PM Hey David, do you have an update on your quixtar efforts? Posted by: Joecool on June 2, 2008 07:29 PM I was a former "IBO" for quixtar, or i mean distributor instead of buisiness owner. I can tell you being out of the business I see what is truly important to me in life, more so than material things they say you can have if you become a diamond, ect in supporting your business. Im a manager at a grocery store and I can tell you I have a couple thousand dollars sitting in my bank account and I have alot more time on my hands. Some of the best things in life are free! I know have more TIME and MONEY, than I ever did with being an IBO! Life is great, its all what you make out of it! Posted by: havejava on June 21, 2008 07:17 PM I saw whole conversation and by the grace of god I have attended many of suchkind of meetings. Quixtar give it as name of E-Commerce but it is simplpy MLM(Multy Level Marketing). Many of the post authors are rightly saying that why only one in Diamond category instead of all of them... Dude its all about making others convience and making ur downline work for you so u get money widout working. This is kinda Immoral. Circuit City and others earn money from this so for them nothing is illegal... Posted by: CP on August 7, 2008 10:33 AM CP, you are right. Other businesses like Walmart may have critics, but those critics don't call Walmart a scam like critics of the quixtar tools kingpins. Posted by: Joecool on August 8, 2008 12:27 PM I've been contacted twice to join one of these joints and I had 2 friends who joined them. I thought about becoming a member also. So here are some of my thoughts: Any other job has a clear description: build 3 houses instead of 2 in the same amount of time. Get your website done in 2 weeks instead of 6 months... you get my point. In case you're a talented guy that can convince even strangers to buy anything, you might be better off working in sales for a big company. Those bonuses are great - I've never heard of a successful salesman complaining about playing golf with partners. And if you're good in selling, you probably have no problem selling yourself in interviews either. I congratulate everyone who actually made it. However, I also feel sorry for those that have to lie about how much they made to cover up their "hopefully" once-in-a-lifetime mistake. I spent some time writing this hoping that I might have saved someones time and money by trying. Get a real job or come up with your own business idea! Posted by: ray on December 15, 2008 08:02 PM Don't do it, you'll regret it Posted by: on December 15, 2008 08:04 PM Currently, I like my way of living and having a ton of money doesn't buy you happiness... Don't worry, unless you're one of the few upper-levels who make money an entirely different way (off teaching materials and events) you won't get the chance to let a ton of money change your character. But you can spend a lot of cash and time learning what not to do! :-)
You have to be one of the founders, or one of the "Diamonds" who makes money as described above. Of course, even then, it depends upon what "works" mean. If "working" means making money without scamming others, then it never "works." In these events you only talk to the people that don't do the work. They want you to work... Well, half right. They're generally "working" too. Only none of that "work" actually produces any economic value. But you're right in thinking that they're trying to recruit you so that they can stop working so hard at it. Posted by: Tim (Random Observations) on December 16, 2008 01:07 PM The reason why some people in Quixtar can get "residual income" AKA getting something for nothing, is they need ot get enough mislead downline to do the work for them. Thus the downline gets nothing for something while the upline kingpin gets something for nothing. Even wonder why many diamonds talk about early retirement yet they are still working? Posted by: Joecool on December 17, 2008 01:58 PM I'm an IBO, and I have not heard of one diamond who is still working and hasn't retired. The business is the business, its the team that you are on that makes it or breaks it. I was not promised anything when I started. I still have a very good full time job now. I make some money, yes, but no not enough to retire off of, but I didn't get into this to retire. 1) I love the products, so why not get paid a little to eat and drink 2) I have made dozens of friends through the team, some better than others and 3)theres wasn't any reason not to for me. So I challenge you now to give me a respectable and provable reason as why not to get into this. And now understand that each team teaches differently and has differenent business perspectives and what not. So with that being said everything you heard about that one person experienced may not be true with me. So how bout it? Posted by: Me on December 31, 2008 09:07 AM Me: So I challenge you now to give me a respectable and provable reason as why not to get into this. Joecool says: I suspect you are not sincere about this, but I will give it a shot: 1. The average income of an active IBO is $115 a month before expenses. Amway discarded the IBOs who do nothing from their count. 2. Many IBOs shoot for platinum. A fraction of 1% of IBOs reach platinum. Platinum does not guarantee you a net profit if you are dedicated to a teaching system. Only a fraction of 1% of platinums ever go onto diamond. 3. The pyramidal nature of the compensation plan ensures that most IBOs make little or nothing so a few can succeed. 4. The prices of products are not competitive. Amway builds in at least a 30%+ margin to cover the cost of IBO bonuses. 5. The company has a shady reputation because of trick or deceptive IBOs who use questionable recruitment tactics. 6. Buying from Amway is actually not good for your local economy. Profit goes to Amway and your neighborhood store loses a sale. I hope I addressed your concern. U have more if you request. p.s. Happy New Year! Posted by: Joecool on December 31, 2008 11:55 AM Ok, I understand what you're saying completely, but $115 is better than nothing. Also, you do have to put the time, effort, money, and work into any business to make money. The "average" IBO is just that, "average" and they don't do much of anything to have their business succeed. I don't think the diamond thing applies to me. I'm not into this business to become wealthy and quit my job. I just wanted to make a few extra bucks and liked the products. The pyramidal nature of the compensation plan looks like any organization. The CEO makes the most and then some managers and then all the laborers. Pretty much the same isn't it? The prices of products actually are dropping on the 3rd and will continue to drop prices on many diff items until well into April. Also, the price of an XS energy can is far less than a red bull and is a whole crap load better for you than it. The company has not a shady reputation at all, they are known for good products and thats that, but its the business teams that do quixtar who make it shady. Some use one method and others use different methods. Some do try and get you to buy books and CD's and all that, some don't. Some will promise you that you can be a millionaire, some won't. It all depends on the team you are working with. Just because one team does it wrong, does not mean that it 1)can't be done correctly and 2)that quixtar is a bad business at all. My neighbor hood store is a walmart, so frankly I don't care if they lose a sale! Listen, I'm not trying to tell you that you are wrong or that I hate you or this or that. I'm actually doing my research and trying to find things out about it all. Are you an IBO now or were you ever? Also, what team were you on? TTYS Posted by: Me on December 31, 2008 11:57 PM Ok, I understand what you're saying completely, but $115 is better than nothing. Also, you do have to put the time, effort, money, and work into any business to make money. The "average" IBO is just that, "average" and they don't do much of anything to have their business succeed. I don't think the diamond thing applies to me. I'm not into this business to become wealthy and quit my job. I just wanted to make a few extra bucks and liked the products. The pyramidal nature of the compensation plan looks like any organization. The CEO makes the most and then some managers and then all the laborers. Pretty much the same isn't it? The prices of products actually are dropping on the 3rd and will continue to drop prices on many diff items until well into April. Also, the price of an XS energy can is far less than a red bull and is a whole crap load better for you than it. The company has not a shady reputation at all, they are known for good products and thats that, but its the business teams that do quixtar who make it shady. Some use one method and others use different methods. Some do try and get you to buy books and CD's and all that, some don't. Some will promise you that you can be a millionaire, some won't. It all depends on the team you are working with. Just because one team does it wrong, does not mean that it 1)can't be done correctly and 2)that quixtar is a bad business at all. My neighbor hood store is a walmart, so frankly I don't care if they lose a sale! Listen, I'm not trying to tell you that you are wrong or that I hate you or this or that. I'm actually doing my research and trying to find things out about it all. Are you an IBO now or were you ever? Also, what team were you on? TTYS Posted by: Me on December 31, 2008 11:58 PM Ok, I understand what you're saying completely, but $115 is better than nothing. Also, you do have to put the time, effort, money, and work into any business to make money. The "average" IBO is just that, "average" and they don't do much of anything to have their business succeed. I don't think the diamond thing applies to me. I'm not into this business to become wealthy and quit my job. I just wanted to make a few extra bucks and liked the products. The pyramidal nature of the compensation plan looks like any organization. The CEO makes the most and then some managers and then all the laborers. Pretty much the same isn't it? The prices of products actually are dropping on the 3rd and will continue to drop prices on many diff items until well into April. Also, the price of an XS energy can is far less than a red bull and is a whole crap load better for you than it. The company has not a shady reputation at all, they are known for good products and thats that, but its the business teams that do quixtar who make it shady. Some use one method and others use different methods. Some do try and get you to buy books and CD's and all that, some don't. Some will promise you that you can be a millionaire, some won't. It all depends on the team you are working with. Just because one team does it wrong, does not mean that it 1)can't be done correctly and 2)that quixtar is a bad business at all. My neighbor hood store is a walmart, so frankly I don't care if they lose a sale! Listen, I'm not trying to tell you that you are wrong or that I hate you or this or that. I'm actually doing my research and trying to find things out about it all. Are you an IBO now or were you ever? Also, what team were you on? TTYS Posted by: Me on December 31, 2008 11:58 PM Sorry about that, my computer was acting up. My fault and I don't know how to delete any of the posts. Posted by: Me on December 31, 2008 11:59 PM Me- I think the point is that the average person doing Amway gets a very very low return on their time investment, even much lower than from a minimum wage job. The only way that a person can "succeed" is to convince a large number of people below them to work for, on average, far less than minimum wage by drastically misrepresenting how much they can expect to earn per hour worked. Posted by: Ryan W. on January 1, 2009 01:25 AM Many companies and organizations have a pyramid shaped organizational chart. The difference is that in a job or company, all employees get paid and have a net gain at the end of the month. Also, the money is made from customers. In Quixtar, many of the lower tiered IBOs make nothing and possibly suffer losses if they are in the tools system. Yes, there are some teams who operate ethically, but many do not. How would someone know whether they are in a good group or not? WHy doesn't the corporation seek and shut down the bad teams? Posted by: Joecool on January 2, 2009 10:29 AM Add your two cents...
The comment rules will apply. Please post only once. |
Funny, I always hear from IBOs how awesome the teaching system is and I ask them to kindly explain 1 or 2 things that upline taught (at a function or on tape)that will help them to run a profitable quixtar business.
I am still waiting..........
Posted by: Joecool18 on July 17, 2006 04:27 PM