|
What's the average cost of a electric bill in the US? According to this study, back in 2004, it was $1400 a year, or a little over $100 each month. Try this: Go to Al Gore's "Carbon Calculator", and tell it you live alone in the US (no specific state), drive 12,000 miles per year (the national average) in an average-sized car (I chose a 2006 Ford Taurus, which gets 20-27 MPG -- the US average), and pay NOTHING for electricity, natural gas or oil. (Which it rounds up to $25 per month.) And tell it you NEVER FLY anywhere. And what's your carbon footprint? I got 7.55 tons per year, where the average is allegedly 7.5 tons per year. Clearly, something is amiss here. I doubt that the average American never flies, and pays that little for their utility bills. I found I could make my average go down by claiming I had several people living in my household. So if I had 3 people in my house, and (improbably) still paying zero money for electricity, then I'd finally be beating the national average. Yet, with three people still in the house, change the electric bill to the national average ($100-$120/month) and you'll find it claims you're spewing 9.5 tons of CO2 each year: more than 25% above the national average. "LARGER THAN AVERAGE" you are condemned to read. So, given average mileage, average electric bill, an average car, and average driving distance, living in an average state, does average American also supposedly have at least 5 people in their house or apartment, NEVER fly anywhere, pay less than $25 each month for natural gas and fuel oil? In the magic land of Albert Gore, the answer is apparently YES! Of course, the calculator assumes the only pollution a car generates is while you drive it (false: hybrids have a higher lifetime per-mile cost than a Hummer H3), and that "green" power sources don't require any CO2 emissions in their construction, operation, or maintenance (false again), but hey, what do you expect. Just click a link, offer to pay a for-profit LLC (which promises no audits or accountability) about $100 (the most expensive per-offset cost on the market) and your annual carbon sins are apparently forgiven! Interesting! I'll give another try when I get a few more moments. What browser were you using? Posted by: Tim (Random Observations) on October 15, 2007 01:20 AM I was using Safari; I get the same result with IE7. I'll have to try it with FireFox when I have time... -TCG Posted by: The Complete Geek on October 15, 2007 04:40 AM TCG: You apparently didn't complete the form by filling in the average electric, natural gas, heating oil, and propane bills with "$0 - 25" per month, the lowest available choice. When you do, the carbon footprint rises to 7.55. That probably explains the difference, and some of the error: the form forces everyone to fill in at least $300 each year (or $150, if its using the average) for each of these four kinds of utilities (resulting in a minimum of $600 fuel consumption each year) whether you use them or not. Posted by: Tim (Random Observations) on October 29, 2007 01:51 AM Thanks! I tried again, and I think I see a further mistake I made: I was using a different state. I get 7.55 tons year^-1 for Delaware, Iowa, and Missouri (the total varies quite a bit from state to state). -TCG Posted by: The Complete Geek on October 29, 2007 06:20 AM Add your two cents...
The comment rules will apply. Please post only once. |
I tried it and got 5.1. Am I missing something?
-TCG
Posted by: The Complete Geek on October 14, 2007 03:32 PM