I wondered about that. Seemed out of character.
Chavez backs anti-democratic elements throughout South America. Likewise, in our country, it's those who yell "Democracy" loudest who seem to love Chavez most. They have an understanding of "true democracy" meaning not a simple outcome of the vote, but an overturning of the current unjust order of things. For example, Noam Chomsky:
By "public control", Chomsky means "government control." Chomsky is, in effect, angry that people can own and control their own resources. For example, if I hire someone to landscape my yard, and I don't like what they're doing, I can decide to stop paying them my money and ask them to get out of my yard. No, no, says Chomsky. "The people" (which inevitably only means people in power who agree with Noam) need to control my money and how I spend it, and on whom. In short, Chomsky is saying that as long as the Constitutional protection of private property exists, we don't have a Democracy. And his statement above is simply a restatement of Marx's complaint that the "capitalists" control the means of production, and that this needs to end. The old Communists were honest enough to admit what they were; the new ones pretend they embody Constitutional ideals and their allies in the media enable this deception. Chavez pretends to care for the poor, and shares the goals of the left. He will interfere with rich private individuals, who the left sees as a bigger threat than the state. So he's their friend, and a good guy. For these individuals, "Democracy" is about justice (as they define it) not primarily about freedom. "The will of the people" is thus rhetorically transmuted from the vote (which is not really democratic since the poor mind-controlled saps don't know any better) into unchecked rule by a small elite who will express only my ideals. Add your two cents...
The comment rules will apply. Please post only once. |
By "public control", Chomsky means "government control."
Being an anarcho-syndicalist, Chomsky might mean union control. But small difference, as far as I can tell.
Posted by: Ryan W. on December 14, 2007 10:01 PM